Someone is wrong on (and about) the internet

XKCD - a most excellent webcomic

Ahh, the internet, the great equalizer where everyone’s voice counts… Being in Silicon Valley, I sometimes forget the rest of the country doesn’t necessarily live and breathe new gadgets and online experiences. That being said, I also don’t understand when people misconstrue what the internet is all about. A recent article on slate.com by Marshall Herskovitz, TV and film producer, has an interesting outlook that I couldn’t leave alone. Here is his introductory pitch to explaining the internet experience…

So I took a break, because I’ve never been happy serving anyone. And went to the Internet where I could be free. At least that’s what everyone told me. The Internet is the “Great Democratizer” where anything goes! You can do whatever you want! Uh—not exactly.Why? Well, let’s look more closely at what the Internet actually is. If, as they say, it’s a vast sea of information, the first thing to realize is that this sea is only accessible from certain harbors called browsers, like Internet Explorer or Safari. And, extending the metaphor further, all the information on this sea is contained in boats called Web sites. And then you begin to understand the problem. It turns out that this sea is invisible to us, untouchable, unusable. Our relationship to the Internet is entirely made up of our relationship to browsers and Web sites. And you know what? They suck.
They’re boring, one-dimensional, and unoriginal. Who decided that all Web sites should have a top nav bar and be rectangular in layout? Who decided they should abdicate any sense of design and be white and clean and uncluttered? No one did, and that’s the point. It just happened, because the creators of the Internet were thinking about other things.

From this (and the rest of his rant), I can only surmise that Mr. Herskovitz must not understand the internet. Maybe someone should create an user manual to help new users out.

I think the way Hollywood portrays the internet in movies and TV has led to some interesting misconceptions and confusion to what the internet is about and how people interact with it. The reality may not have the futuristic interfaces or 1-click access to anything (DMV information, Pentagon restricted access, etc…), but it’s still pretty damn cool. I can’t imagine life without full connectivity and the ability to learn and discover to my heart’s content. The internet brings walls down and brings people together. I look forward to what the future holds and enjoy what it provides today.

February 26, 2008. Tags: , . internet, social, technology.

2 Comments

  1. Ronin replied:

    While you’re very right that there are many misconceptions and confusion to what the Internet is about and what does it mean to ordinary internauts, your perception of the Internet in Silicon Valley is much different than the one people have in other parts of the real world.
    Restricting access to the Internet is like turning lights off, however it happened many times and happens still. Just check this out and think about it:
    “1992- Serbia has had a 9.6 kbit/s leased line between Beograd and Linz to
    carry EARN traffic. Currently this line is cut according to a decision
    of the Austrian government about the UN embargo of new Yugoslavia.” Source RIPE
    Check also news on Pakistani government blocking YouTube for more recent example.

  2. jnusser replied:

    I completely agree that access to the internet should always be available and unrestricted, regardless of where in the world someone is located. That’s one of the aspects that makes it so powerful. Governments restrict or block access in a futile attempt to keep their citizens in the dark. If I’ve seen one thing, though, it is that the internet is extremely hard to keep quiet. It always finds a way around the obstacle, be that a dictator, oppression, or greedy businesses.

Leave a Reply

Trackback URI